Properties listed in Shelter Island

Three bedroom and 2 bath farmhouse with big wrap around porch, on a tree lined street close to the town center.  Eat in Kitchen, sitting room, living room, outd ...

Beautiful home on a quiet road with water views.  Walking distance to the beach and Rams Head Inn.  Very clean and comfortable 3 bedroom, 2 bath ranch with cent ...

First time ever on the market! Sited on 2+ serene acres lies a 2BR and 1BA Farmhouse Cottage with exquisite gardens. The colors are constantly changing between ...

Bright and airy and recently renovated Contemporary that is close to ferry, shopping, dining, golf and tennis. Plus a heated pool. Large wrap around deck with o ...

Brand new to the market with great rental rates. Open floor plan, beautiful sunlit enclosed porch, entertaining deck overlooking quiet grassy yard, and outdoor ...

Airy, spacious 2-story home has 3 bedrooms, 1.5 baths, full kitchen, dining room, spacious living room with fireplace and deck. Convenient to town center and sc ...

Secluded water view Contemporary across from water access. Offers 3BR, 2BA, a bright well equipped kitchen, lots of entertaining space including screen porch, g ...

A Mid-Century Ranch with incredible water views, so close you practically feel the salt spray. A perfect summer getaway with 4BR, 2.5BA in the Hay Beach/Dering ...

Perfect summer rental. A 3BR, 2BA single story that has been recently renovated. Large backyard deck for outside dining, close to beaches in a quiet neighborhoo ...

Freshly renovated and designed to be cool and comfortable. There are 4 BR's and 2 full baths, large open kitchen, Living Room with brick fireplace and lovely en ...

Charming 3BR, 2BA get away with entertaining deck with water views of Smith's Cove. Private association sandy beach to walk to and close to Mashomack for hiking ...

Near Coecles Harbor and marina for boating and swimming. Old style 4BR, 1.5BA Farmhouse that is very clean and neat. Outside shower, eat in Kitchen, 2 covered p ...