Homes for Rent

Stunning waterfront property with a private deep water dock that can accommodate larger boats. Ample deck space surrounds the home and dock complete with an out ...

Beautifully appointed 3BR house + office, 2.5 bathrooms in Shelter Island (Hay Beach area). The office can be fully closed and used as a guest bedroom. The hous ...

Absolutely gorgeous and spacious 5 bedroom, 3.5 bath farmhouse with pool, wrap around porch, finished basement & attic recreation space. Close proximity to ...

Tasteful and stylish, this 4BR , 4BA Contemporary offers large open floor plan, a library, den, and office. The large open Great Room with fireplace, vaulted ce ...

Beautiful 4 bedroom, 4 bath waterfront home right around the corner from Shell Beach.  Central air, private beach with mooring, private dock and floating dock.  ...

Great summer spot for families with water views and short walk to shell beach!  3 bedrooms 2 baths, central air, washer & dryer, tons of board games, large ...

Beautifully updated and bright 3 bedroom 2 bath ranch on a quiet street.  Eat in kitchen, open living & dining room, great room with fireplace, central air, ...

Bright and open 4 bedroom 3 bath contemporary home with a spacious floor plan and plenty of exterior areas to lounge and BBQ on the deck or by the heated pool. ...

Enjoy the sunset views from this 3 bedroom, 3 bath, waterside home with pool or step down to your own private beach. June-LD $125,000; June $30,000; July $55,00 ...

Perfect summer location on Shelter Island, with a large deck and private beach access. Enjoy this updated and modern 3 bedroom 2 bath home with CAC, fireplace, ...

Three bedroom and 2 bath farmhouse with big wrap around porch, on a tree lined street close to the town center.  Eat in Kitchen, sitting room, living room, outd ...

Beautiful home on a quiet road with water views.  Walking distance to the beach and Rams Head Inn.  Very clean and comfortable 3 bedroom, 2 bath ranch with cent ...